The story chronicles his time there through the eyes of his friend red. When there are book adaptations there are usually more differences than similarities, but the shawshank redemption is completely the opposite. Surprisingly, there were more similarities between the novella and the film then i expected. This is the reason why he adds his memory at the end of the movie. The shawshank redemption is only one of the short stories in this book. Allen greene was a literary agent, 3time academy awardnominated director, frank darabonts, agent, and personal friend. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption theme free essays. Shawshank redemption books that are made into movies are always changed, even if they are minor changes, but changes are made nonetheless.
The only really major difference between the king and darabont versions is the casting of morgan freeman as red. Rita hayworth is an american actress from the 1940s. It tells the story of banker andy dufresne tim robbins, who is sentenced to life in shawshank state penitentiary for the murders of his wife and her lover, despite his. The novella is better than the movie, is that in the movie brooks hangs himself and shows he doesnt want to live on the outside. A lot of book adaptations usually have more differences than similarities, but the shawshank redemption is completely the opposite. With tim robbins, morgan freeman, bob gunton, william sadler. Sep 24, 2014 the shawshank redemption was a dud upon its theatrical release in 1994, yet somehow it made a lasting impression and became the classic that it is today. In the movies, red is played by morgan freeman and hes not irish.
When i first started researching the film version of contact, i quickly noted many of the differences between the novel which i had already finished reading and the movie which i had yet to view. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption the margos finally take on this classic stephen kingfrank darabont movie youre welcome. Stephen kings novella rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption is a great book, but the movie manages to be even better in a variety of ways. Shawshank redemption never felt like anything but a story. According to internet movie database users, that is exactly the case. Differences between the shawshank redeption book vs movie page 5. Andy escapes heres the scene of andys escape from the 1994 movie. Differences in the movie and book of shawshank redemption essaysthe novella the shawshank redemption and rita hayworth, by stephen king, is the basis of the 1994 movie the shawshank redemption directed by frank darabont. The film and novella still have their differences but there similarities stand out. Two imprisoned men bond over a number of years, finding solace and eventual redemption through acts of common decency. Unlike the book, andy has a revenge on shawshank in the movie, so the delight is more intense. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption replay the margos celebrate the 25th anniversary of this. Shawshank redemption novella and film compare and contrast the 1994 film the shawshank redemption takes it inspiration from the stephen king novella rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption, the first of four stories collected in his 1982 book different seasons.
The novella the shawshank redemption and rita hayworth, by stephen king, is the basis of the 1994 movie the shawshank redemption directed by frank darabont. The characters, especially red, are described in different ways in the two pieces. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption electronic media. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption there is always allot of discussion on a book vs. Nov 29, 2017 its tough to read the same book again and again. This moving and inspirational film follows the book very closely in relation to.
Novella by stephen king, as part of different seasons, published in 1982. And not just shawshank, imagine godfather series, reading the book vs movie series. There are many themes represented in each form of the shawshank redemption. If i were given a choice of which to watch right now, it would be shawshank. I also liked the part when norton opens the bible and notices the hole for the rockhammer. The advent of the internet likely brought together the largest congregation of movie fans in history, ready to express their opinions in the most accessed movie data base ever, and the best rated film there is the shawshank redemption. The shawshank redemption is a 1994 american drama film written and directed by frank darabont, based on the 1982 stephen king novella rita hayworth and shawshank redemption. In a new series, we discuss over texts the merits and flaws of famous books and. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption 25th anniversary.
Finally, the movie shows red crossing the border and meeting up with andy in mexico. Having just finished reading the book an hour ago, i can name a few. He adapted the film from stephen king s 1982 novel rita hayworth and shawshank redemption. Dec 06, 2010 differences between the movie and book. The book and novella still have their differences but there similarities stand out. The shawshank redemption by stephen king is both a wonderful film and a brilliantly written short story. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption is a short story by stephen king from his 1982 collection different seasons, subtitled hope springs eternal. How the shawshank redemption is an ideal adaptation from. Directed by frank darabont in 1994 comparing the book and movie of the shawshank redemption is like comparing a warm chocolate chip cookie and a brownie right out of the oven.
Is frank darabonts the shawshank redemption the best motionpicture of all time. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we launched the show and finally had the time to get it together. In a new series, we discuss over texts the merits and flaws of famous books. Andy dufresne is headed to shawshank prison for a murder he is sure he did not commit, though the evidence is not in his favor. The shawshank redeption book vs movie add a difference. Rita hayworth was the girl on the poster that andy used to hide the hole that he was digging. The advent of the internet likely brought together the largest congregation of movie fans in history, ready to express their opinions in the most accessed movie data base ever, and the best rated film there is the shawshank. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption archives margo donohue. The main characters are red redding and andy dufresne.
The shawshank redemption is a fascinating film, which written and directed by frank darabont in 1994. Rita hayworth and shawshank redemption essay 1208 words. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we launched the show and finally had the time. One thing i and many others love about the movie is the ability it has to all come together at the end.
In the movie tommy williams is moved to a different prison after andy tells the warden that he has information that might free him. It has been thought to be loosely based on the leo tolstoy short story god sees the truth, but waits. What are the differences between shawshank redemption book and movie. There are a ton of differences between the book and the classic 1994 film adaptation, directed by frank darabont, but those differences lie in. According to brooks hatlin, this is the year he enters shawshank prison.
Filmnovel comparison rita hayworth and the shawshank. Unfortunately, he died from aids complications just before the release of the shawshank redemption. The shawshank redemption was a dud upon its theatrical release in 1994, yet somehow it made a lasting impression and became the classic that it is today. Given the remit of studios todaythe remit for blockbuster highenergy and flashi dont think the film could be made. Differences between the shawshank redeption book vs movie page 1. There were only a few minor changes made in the process from making the book into a motion picture film. It was a really decent adaptation of the book novella.
Play in new window book vs movie the shawshank redemption the margos finally take on this classic stephen kingfrank darabont movie youre welcome. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption introduction. Feb 14, 2017 there are a ton of differences between the book and the classic 1994 film adaptation, directed by frank darabont, but those differences lie in the decision to expand the character arcs in the book. Its odd that i have read stephen kings the body but havent read rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption, given that they shared space in the same collection. The film takes place at shawshank prison in maine from the 1940s through the 1960s. In the book, red is a white man with red hair, and his age is similar to andys. What are the differences between shawshank redemption book.
Book vs movie the shawshank redemption archives margo. The movie was released in 1994 with the understandably shortened title the shawshank redemption. The shawshank redemption was actually a stephen king book before it was a movie, and here are the big differences from page to screen. The ending, the beginning, the whole movie is just exciting, entertaining, and lastly, puzzling.
Whats the difference between rita hayworth and shawshank redemption the book and the shawshank redeption the movie. The similarities and differences are what make one better than the other, and that there is for you to decide. Rita hayworth and shawshank redemption essay 1208 words cram. Comparing the book and movie of the shawshank redemption is like comparing a warm chocolate chip cookie and a brownie right out of the oven. When it comes down to it, they both hit that sweet spot and are better than the other during the moment you are eating them.
How similar is the movie contact to carl sagans book of. There are some classic movies like shawshank redemption which i may have watched almost 5o times but never got bored of it. I quickly began forming prejudices in my mind against the film, expecting far too much to be changed from the book version. For detailed analysis on the shawshank redemption, check out my shawshank redemption. Over the years, he retains hope and eventually gains the respect of his fellow inmates, especially longtime convict red redding, a black marketeer, and becomes influential within the prison. If there is one thing we can say about book vs movie fansthey love the stephen king eps and cannot get enough of them. King, which was adapted for the screen in 1994 by the director frank darabont. Nothing quite like comparing one of the best movies of all time with its source material. Book vs movie the shawshank redemption replay the margos celebrate the 25th anniversary of this classic film if there is one thing we can say about book vs movie fansthey love the stephen king eps and cannot get enough of them. Differences between the shawshank redeption book vs movie.
Tailor made cigarettes, a bag of reefer if youre partial to that, a bottle of brandy to celebrate your son or daughters high school graduation, or anything else within reason, that is. King books had been notoriously difficult to bring to the screen. In this video, we take a look at how it adds to its. The booktofilm adaptation of the cinema classic, starring tim robbins and morgan freeman, contains more differences than imagined. The film leaves out a number of characters, its more actionoriented than the novel, a major event in the film happens in a completely different manner in the book and a major character in the film has different motivations than in. The movies differ wherein they show andy approach the bank and also show him exposing the corruption at shawshank. The shawshank redemption is one of the greatest films ever. I often think that shorter stories make for easier movie adaptations as the filmmakers dont have to trim material the same way. If youve seen the movie either shawshank or green mile, pick up the novels that started it all, if the movies had you on the edge of your seat, the novels will probably turn your knuckles white. But then i dont often read novellas and short stories, as i prefer novels. Andy entered shawshank in 1948 and escaped in the year 1975 27 years. Differences in the movie and book of shawshank redemption. Shawshank is a quiet little story about friendship. Sep 20, 2019 book vs movie the shawshank redemption replay the margos celebrate the 25th anniversary of this.
However, it was almost a perfect story with a perfect ending and perfect casting. Apr 03, 2012 comparing the book and movie of the shawshank redemption is like comparing a warm chocolate chip cookie and a brownie right out of the oven. This moving and inspirational film follows the book very closely in relation to the characters and plot, however, it does include some very significant changes. Tommy is shot and killed by hadley under the pretense that he was trying to escape. The one major theme that interests me in both the film and the story is freedom. Rita hayworth and the shawshank redemption theres a guy like me in every state and federal prison in america, i guessim the guy who can get it for you. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we launched the show and finally had. After the murder of his wife, hotshot banker andrew dufresne is sent to shawshank prison, where the usual unpleasantness occurs. In particular, we have been getting requests for the shawshank redemption since we. While the film retains much of the novellas plot and structure, it nonetheless diverges. The book prepares the reader for reds next destination. Tommy williams is moved to a different prison after andy tells the warden that he has information that might free him. Published on feb 14, 2017 there are a ton of differences between the book and the classic 1994 film adaptation, directed by frank darabont, but those differences lie in the decision to expand the.
1017 1650 1010 910 667 42 1200 612 4 1039 534 1276 689 426 933 1204 43 984 20 1275 884 1497 178 783 1280 1543 1214 585 1109 1405 959 1537 1452 22 1182 474 1375 1385 369 841 561